Her Story with minor spoilers

I spent about three hours on the weekend playing the wonderful Her Story. As someone who grew up gaming in the 80/90s and lived through Night Trap and Mad Dog McCree, the negative reception FMV based games received then is still quite firm in my mind. It would be a disservice to lump Her Story in with FMV games that preceded it, group it with visual novels or “experience” games where you basically watch the plot unfold before you.

The one line spiel is you’re searching clips of a police interview with a woman around a 1994 crime. piecing together the series of events to solve the case. The core of the game is practically a database simulator, with the FMV existing to provide more clues for your next query as each clip has been transcribed, but there are also some hints provided by some subtle visual clues. The fragments of the interviews you unearth slowly shed light on what happened, but each one also raises new questions. The clips you watched 30 minutes ago now have a completely different meaning, and open up a new set of terms to query the database with.

Without spoiling too much, the more you uncover it becomes less about what actually happened and more about why. Which brings me to the refreshing part of Her Story – the plot is largely structured around how you interpret and piece together the video clips you uncover. I might have a different interpretation based on the clips I unlocked and the order I viewed them in.

The fact searching a database and watching some grainy FMV is so compelling is a testament to the brilliant editing – even the shortest clip could contain a clue that unlocks a new piece of information. I finished with around 90% of the interview clips unlocked, and still felt I hadn’t completely solved the crime but had a pretty good understanding of what happened and why. Even if I had swung back and forth between the most probable situations a number of times before I saw the credits.

It shies away from the obvious conclusion of actually giving firm closure, it’s up to you  to fill in the blanks. Having sat through a few hours of investigations to form your own conclusion, and then be told your analysis was wrong would have been a horrible ending to a fantastic experience. Another instance of less being more, which is so rare in gaming today.

Round 15 NRL Supercoach thoughts

Late NRL Supercoach thoughts for round 15 this week unfortunately, but better late than never:

  • For the second week in a row I’ve stuffed up my VC. Last week it was Dylan Walker over James Tedesco. This week it was moving to Thurston from Shaun Johnson. Once JT  was named it seemed like the best option. I was sweating bullets seeing Johnson on 170 after the Titans game. Luckily he was downgraded to 150ish making it less of an issue. My captain was Andrew Fifita, who scored in the 60s despite Gallen not playing.
  • Not only was I reeling from missing out on doubling Johnson’s score, but James Segeyaro going off with 30 points and a medial ligament strain in his knee made things worse. He’s a hold for the time being but could be traded out in 17 if I want to risk some trades.
  • Jack Bird’s 134 (upgraded from mid 90s) saved my H2H and cemented his place in my team for the rest of the season. A definite keeper.
  • Kyle Lovett getting 72 on Friday night was a nice surprise, but unfortunately I had him as an NPR. Still he will play 80 minutes in Round 17 and has some price rises left
  • The continued rise of Jack Bird into Supercoach keeper range is both hysterical and depressing. Could have easily made 200k+ if I’d jumped on in round 13/14.
  • Maumalo injuring his leg and possibly not playing again this season isn’t the worst thing in the world, his 14 was a horrible AE for some coaches. If he sits on the bench he’s basically a dual CTW/2RF nuff which is fine with me.
  • Two trades made this week. Lichaa has performed admirably and has been sent packing for Cameron Smith, who is probably the cheapest he’ll be all season. The other was Soliola to Luke Lewis. Lewis has an achievable BE and plays 17 & 18 with an average around 65 if you take out his first two games back from injury. I’m light on players for rounds 17 and 18, especially in light of the Segeyaro injury so I need to start adding some players who cover both. Should be using the full four trades next week.

Round 14 Supercoach thoughts

Some quick NRL Supercoach thoughts from round 14 :

  • Leaving my VC on Walker instead of Tedesco (who I had as VC in NRL Fantasy, where you can’t loop), cost me around 130 points. I’ll never learn.
  • Judging by my 4 leagues I’m probably around average so far, and won’t pick up too many places overall. Was quite difficult to build a unique sides this round without burning trades, given who was playing.
  • Happy I hung on to Solomone Kata this long, he should increase in value nicely for a trade in round 17
  • Low scoring game from Adam Reynolds will have him in a good position by round 17, but since Souths miss 18 he could probably be picked up then
  • Mannering as captain was what I expected. Matulino had a solid game but nothing outstanding and I don’t feel too bad not spending a trade on him
  • Dodged a bullet by not picking up Bodene Thompson, two low scores in a row and some bad misses defending his goal line. Ditto Blake Ferguson, who had 51 thanks to the last second try.
  • Wish I had an easy way to bring in James Roberts this week. I would have had to sacrifice Soliola or Bird to bring him in, which would have helped this round but will feel better once we know what Roberts leg injury is and if he is out long term. He was the only other person I was looking at seriously bringing in after Maumalo, but just couldn’t find a way that worked long term. So just one trade used, 16 to go.
  • H2H rests on 9 points versus Captain Semi. Already taking the L (edit: Monday update put me behind 2 points before Semi even hit the field)
  • Nathan Peats thinks he tore his ACL again, so there’s one trade this week, most likely for Segeyaro
  • Holdig Tohu Harris paid off as he picked up a try on the way to 87. Could be worth holding until 17 or even 18 if his price remains steady
  • Round score is 958 before Tuesday updates, but there’s some high 1100’s in my leagues. Hopefully will see a small increase for Jarryd Hayne’s Knee.

Steam sale apathy

I always thought my first blog post would be about my beloved Golden State Warriors and the ups and downs of following them from Australia for the past 25 years. It’s taken me a while to finally start a blog to talk about them, despite threatening to do so for years. I’ve waited so long that it can no longer be complaining about poor draft choices, horrible trades, or Chris Cohan. Being part of the NBA Finals right now, there’s been so much being written about them that I don’t feel I have anything new and/or interesting to add. Eventually that day will come.

Instead it’s a first world gaming whine, which probably fits better in my role as a negative vibe merchant. I’ll probably write a post about that at some point as well.

It’s Sunday evening and I’m current looking at my list of 25 installed games on Steam, and struggling to muster the enthusiasm to spend time with any of them.

The most enjoyable gaming experience I’ve had this year has been Invisible Inc. It ticked all the right boxes for me – developed by Klei Entertainment (I loved Don’t Starve), turn based, stealth, hacking and procedurally generated. There’s a limited amount of content, however it’s designed that way, as you aren’t meant to clear levels before exiting. Each safe or terminal exists as a decision, offering a more credits or items but also increasing the chance of being discovered or terminated.

I had been enjoying The Witcher 3, but unfortunately the claustrophobic field of view was giving me motion sickness after 45 minutes. I’ll come back when there’s a FOV mod that doesn’t break with each update.

There are 45 hours on my play through of Pillars of Eternity, but after taking a break in Act III I’m struggling to get back into it. The late game combat consisting of constant domination feels cheap, although with out it mobs would (and do) feel trivial. I’ve invested enough that I’m determined to see the end of it eventually, even though the story and characters do nothing for me.

You Must Build A Boat is wonderful, but doesn’t feel right with a mouse and keyboard for obvious reasons. Cities: Skylines is similarly fantastic but currently lacks a significant challenge outside of optimising your traffic.

With all that in mind, I’ve been browsing the current (northern) Winter Steam Sale to find something to fill my evening. There’s not a lot that is catching my eye, although I can see Counter Strike Go and Prison Architect with attractive prices, however there’s little chance I’d get much out of either of them. My advancing age and decaying reflexes would probably result in a great deal of frustration playing CS Go. Prison Architect has been regularly recommended to me as someone who enjoys management sims, but the prospect of investing time in an unfinished product doesn’t particularly excite me.

I know that this hardly makes me a unique snowflake, but it is interesting to me how my perception of Steam sales has changed over time. The hope and excitement has evolved into apathy.

So I’ll probably just start yet another game of Civ 5 with some new mods to change things up. Anything to keep me away from that monster clicking meta game.